You’ll need this again. Bookmark this site now!

Behavior reduction is a vital part of applied behavior analysis (ABA), focused on decreasing challenging behaviors by using proven, ethical strategies.

As a Registered Behavior Technician (RBT), it’s essential to understand these approaches to support your clients effectively and safely.

This guide gives you a detailed overview of all aspects of behavior reduction as described in Domain D of the RBT Test Content Outline (3rd edition). You’ll learn how to:

  • Identify common functions of behavior
  • Implement antecedent interventions to prevent problem behaviors
  • Use differential reinforcement techniques to teach alternatives
  • Apply extinction procedures correctly
  • Understand and use punishment procedures when necessary and appropriate
  • Recognize and manage the secondary effects of extinction and punishment
  • Implement crisis and emergency procedures to ensure safety

By following this resource, you’ll be prepared to handle challenging behaviors with confidence, skill, and professionalism, ensuring the best outcomes for your clients and success on the RBT exam.

Note: This study guide is extremely detailed, allowing you to learn everything about RBT Behavior Reduction. You don’t need to look elsewhere; this is the ultimate guide for you, with over 7,000 words.

Bookmark it so you can easily return to it later, as you may not be able to read or fully understand everything in one sitting.

D.1. Identify Common Functions of Behavior

The Four Primary Functions of Behavior

All behaviors serve a purpose. Even challenging behaviors that appear counterproductive or harmful have a function for the individual exhibiting them. According to behavior analytic principles, there are four primary functions of behavior:

  1. Access to Attention (Social Positive Reinforcement)
    • Behaviors maintained by attention seek interaction from others
    • This attention can be positive (praise, conversation) or negative (reprimands, arguments)
    • Examples: A child throws toys when adults are talking to each other; a student calls out in class when the teacher is working with other students
    • Key indicators: Behavior increases when attention is low and decreases when attention is freely available
  2. Access to Tangibles/Activities (Material Positive Reinforcement)
    • Behaviors that result in gaining preferred items or activities
    • Examples: A child screams until given a tablet; a client pushes materials away to gain access to preferred toys
    • Key indicators: Behavior intensifies when access to preferred items is restricted and decreases when items are freely available
  3. Escape/Avoidance (Negative Reinforcement)
    • Behaviors that allow the individual to escape or avoid aversive situations or demands
    • Examples: A student tears up worksheets when given difficult tasks; a client flops to the ground when asked to transition from a preferred activity
    • Key indicators: Behavior occurs during demands or non-preferred activities and decreases when these demands are removed
  4. Automatic Reinforcement (Sensory Stimulation)
    • Behaviors maintained by the sensory feedback they provide, independent of social consequences
    • Can be positive (producing pleasurable sensory stimulation) or negative (reducing aversive internal states)
    • Examples: Hand-flapping that produces visual stimulation; head-banging that masks an internal pain
    • Key indicators: Behavior occurs across multiple settings and in the absence of social consequences

Multiple Functions and Function Variations

It’s important to understand that behaviors can serve multiple functions simultaneously or vary in function across different contexts:

  1. Multi-function behaviors
    • A behavior might serve different functions in different contexts
    • Example: A child might hit peers for attention during group activities but hit staff for escape during instructional demands
    • Assessment must examine the behavior across multiple situations to identify all possible functions
  2. Function hierarchies
    • When behaviors serve multiple functions, there is often a hierarchy of importance
    • Primary and secondary functions may exist for the same behavior
    • Example: Tantrum behavior primarily maintained by escape from demands but secondarily maintained by attention
  3. Shifting functions
    • Functions can shift over time due to changing environmental contingencies
    • A behavior initially maintained by one function may develop additional functions through accidental reinforcement
    • Example: Self-injury initially providing sensory stimulation may also be reinforced by staff attention or removal of demands

Identifying Functions Through Assessment

As an RBT, you will participate in various assessment procedures to identify behavioral functions:

  1. Indirect assessments
    • Structured interviews (e.g., Functional Assessment Interview)
    • Rating scales (e.g., Motivation Assessment Scale, Questions About Behavioral Function)
    • Review of historical records and previous behavior plans
  2. Descriptive assessments
    • ABC (Antecedent-Behavior-Consequence) data collection
    • Continuous recording of events surrounding the behavior
    • Scatter plots to identify temporal patterns
  3. Functional analysis
    • Systematic manipulation of environmental variables to test hypotheses about behavioral function
    • Controlled conditions that isolate potential functions (attention, tangible, escape, automatic)
    • Direct observation and measurement of behavior under these conditions

Function Identification in Practice

When identifying behavioral functions, consider these practical guidelines:

  1. Context matters
    • The same topography (form) of behavior may serve different functions
    • Example: Two clients may engage in similar hitting behavior, but one is seeking attention while the other is escaping demands
  2. Patterns over instances
    • Look for patterns across time rather than focusing on isolated incidents
    • Consider the consistency of antecedents and consequences
  3. Multiple data sources
    • Triangulate information from various assessment methods
    • Compare indirect assessments with direct observation data
    • Consider discrepancies between reported and observed functions
  4. Magnitude and intensity
    • Consider whether the intensity of behavior varies across potential function conditions
    • Higher intensity in specific conditions may indicate a primary function

Understanding behavioral functions is the foundation for selecting appropriate behavior reduction strategies. Without accurate function identification, interventions may be ineffective or even inadvertently strengthen the problematic behavior.

D.2. Implement Antecedent Interventions

Antecedent interventions focus on modifying environmental factors that occur before the target behavior to reduce the likelihood of the behavior occurring. These interventions are preventative in nature and are often preferable to consequence-based strategies because they can prevent challenging behaviors before they occur.

Noncontingent Reinforcement (NCR)

Noncontingent reinforcement involves providing reinforcement on a time-based schedule, independent of the individual’s behavior.

  1. Definition and purpose
    • Delivering reinforcement on a fixed or variable time schedule regardless of behavior
    • Reduces motivation for problem behavior by providing free access to the reinforcer
    • Particularly effective for attention- and tangible-maintained behaviors
  2. Implementation steps
    • Identify the reinforcer maintaining the problem behavior
    • Determine an appropriate schedule for delivering that reinforcer noncontingently
    • Initially, provide reinforcement more frequently than the typical rate of problem behavior
    • Gradually thin the schedule of reinforcement as behavior decreases
  3. Types of NCR schedules
    • Fixed-time (FT): Reinforcer delivery at regular time intervals
    • Variable-time (VT): Reinforcer delivery at varied time intervals around an average
    • Response-independent time (RIT): General term for time-based rather than behavior-based reinforcement
  4. Clinical considerations
    • Ensure the reinforcer provided matches the function of the behavior
    • For attention-maintained behaviors, provide attention on a time schedule
    • For tangible-maintained behaviors, provide access to preferred items on a time schedule
    • For escape-maintained behaviors, provide breaks on a time schedule
  5. Practical examples
    • For a client whose self-injury is maintained by attention, provide attention every 5 minutes regardless of behavior
    • For a client whose aggression is maintained by access to toys, provide access to toys for 2 minutes every 15 minutes
  6. Advantages and limitations
    • Advantages: Non-intrusive, prevents behavior, can be easily implemented
    • Limitations: Initial resources required, potential for reinforcer satiation

High-Probability Request Sequences (High-p)

High-probability request sequences involve presenting a series of requests or commands that the individual is likely to comply with before presenting a low-probability request.

  1. Definition and purpose
    • Delivering 3-5 easy, high-compliance tasks immediately before a difficult request
    • Builds behavioral momentum to increase compliance with the low-probability request
    • Particularly effective for escape-maintained behaviors
  2. Implementation steps
    • Identify high-probability requests (commands with 80%+ compliance history)
    • Identify low-probability requests (commands with history of non-compliance)
    • Present 3-5 high-probability requests in quick succession
    • Provide reinforcement for compliance with each high-p request
    • Immediately follow with the low-probability request
    • Reinforce compliance with the low-probability request
  3. Key parameters
    • Inter-prompt interval: Deliver high-p requests rapidly (2-5 seconds apart)
    • Inter-sequence interval: Deliver the low-p request within 5 seconds of compliance with the last high-p request
    • Reinforcement: Provide reinforcement for each instance of compliance
  4. Practical examples
    • High-p sequence: “Give me five,” “Touch your nose,” “Clap your hands”
    • Low-p request: “Clean up your toys”
    • For a student refusing writing tasks: “Point to the pencil,” “Pick up the pencil,” “Make a mark on the paper,” followed by “Write your name”
  5. Advantages and limitations
    • Advantages: Increases compliance, reduces escape-motivated behaviors, builds positive momentum
    • Limitations: May lose effectiveness over time, requires identifying effective high-p requests

Demand Fading

Demand fading involves gradually introducing demands that typically trigger problem behavior, allowing the individual to adapt to increasing expectations.

  1. Definition and purpose
    • Systematically and gradually increasing task demands over time
    • Reduces the aversiveness of demands by beginning at a manageable level
    • Particularly effective for escape-maintained behaviors
  2. Implementation approaches
    • Duration fading: Gradually increasing the length of work periods
      • Start with brief (e.g., 1-minute) work sessions
      • Gradually increase duration as tolerance improves
      • Example: Work for 1 minute, then 2 minutes, then 5 minutes, etc.
    • Quantity fading: Gradually increasing the amount of work required
      • Start with minimal task requirements (e.g., one math problem)
      • Gradually increase the number of tasks
      • Example: Complete 2 problems, then 3 problems, then 5 problems, etc.
    • Difficulty fading: Gradually increasing the difficulty level of tasks
      • Start with mastered tasks and gradually introduce more challenging components
      • Example: Begin with single-digit addition before introducing double-digit addition
  3. Implementation steps
    • Identify the baseline level of demand the client can tolerate
    • Start below this level to ensure initial success
    • Establish clear criteria for advancing to the next level
    • Reinforce compliance at each step
    • If problem behavior occurs, consider temporary reversal to a previous level
  4. Practical examples
    • For a child who refuses to complete worksheets: Start with one problem, then two problems, etc.
    • For a client who elopes during community outings: Begin with brief (5-minute) community visits, gradually extending the duration
  5. Advantages and limitations
    • Advantages: Builds tolerance for demands, teaches persistence, minimizes escape behaviors
    • Limitations: Progress can be slow, requires consistent implementation

Other Important Antecedent Interventions

While the RBT exam specifically mentions NCR, high-probability sequences, and demand fading, other antecedent strategies are also important to understand:

  1. Environmental modifications
    • Arranging the physical environment to reduce triggers for problem behavior
    • Examples: Reducing noise, adjusting lighting, providing visual supports
    • Particularly effective for behaviors sensitive to sensory stimulation
  2. Choice making
    • Offering structured choices within activities to increase perceived control
    • Examples: Choosing the order of tasks, selecting materials, picking reinforcers
    • Particularly effective for escape-maintained and control-seeking behaviors
  3. Task interspersal
    • Alternating difficult tasks with easier, mastered tasks
    • Similar to high-p sequences but implemented throughout the activity
    • Reduces overall response effort and increases motivation
  4. Behavioral momentum
    • Building compliance through a series of successful responses
    • Begins with easy tasks and gradually shifts to more difficult ones
    • Creates “momentum” that carries through to challenging tasks
  5. Visual schedules and supports
    • Using visual cues to clarify expectations and increase predictability
    • Examples: Visual schedules, first-then boards, visual timers
    • Reduces uncertainty and anxiety that may trigger problem behavior
  6. Premack principle (First-Then)
    • Requiring completion of a less-preferred activity before access to a preferred activity
    • Example: “First homework, then video games”
    • Increases motivation for completing non-preferred tasks

When implementing antecedent interventions, remember that they are most effective when matched to the function of the behavior. Always collect data on the effectiveness of these interventions and be prepared to adjust strategies as needed.

D.3. Implement Differential Reinforcement Procedures

Differential reinforcement is a systematic approach that involves reinforcing specific behaviors while withholding reinforcement for others. These procedures are fundamental to behavior reduction as they focus on teaching and strengthening alternative appropriate behaviors rather than simply decreasing problem behaviors.

Differential Reinforcement of Other Behavior (DRO)

DRO involves delivering reinforcement when the target problem behavior does not occur for a specified period.

  1. Definition and purpose
    • Reinforcement delivered contingent on the absence of the target behavior
    • Also called “omission training” or “differential reinforcement of zero rates”
    • Reduces behavior by reinforcing its non-occurrence
  2. Types of DRO
    • Whole-interval DRO: Reinforcement delivered if the behavior does not occur throughout the entire interval
    • Momentary DRO: Reinforcement delivered if the behavior is not occurring at the moment the interval ends
  3. Implementation steps
    • Identify the target behavior to be reduced
    • Establish a baseline rate of the behavior
    • Set an initial interval slightly shorter than the average time between instances of the behavior
    • Deliver reinforcement when the interval passes without the target behavior
    • Reset the interval if the target behavior occurs
    • Gradually increase the interval length as behavior decreases
  4. Practical examples
    • For a client who engages in self-injury once every 10 minutes: Set an initial DRO interval of 8 minutes, delivering reinforcement if no self-injury occurs during that time
    • For a student who calls out in class: Set a timer for 5 minutes, providing a token if no calling out occurs when the timer sounds
  5. Advantages and limitations
    • Advantages: Simple to implement, does not require identifying replacement behaviors
    • Limitations: Does not teach alternative behaviors, requires constant monitoring

Differential Reinforcement of Alternative Behavior (DRA)

DRA involves reinforcing a specific appropriate behavior that serves as an alternative to the problem behavior.

  1. Definition and purpose
    • Reinforcing an appropriate behavior that achieves the same function as the problem behavior
    • Teaches functionally equivalent alternatives
    • Reduces problem behavior by strengthening competing responses
  2. Implementation steps
    • Identify the function of the problem behavior
    • Select an appropriate alternative behavior that serves the same function
    • Teach the alternative behavior explicitly if not already in repertoire
    • Deliver reinforcement whenever the alternative behavior occurs
    • Withhold reinforcement for the problem behavior (often combined with extinction)
    • Ensure reinforcement for the alternative behavior is at least as valuable and immediate as the reinforcement previously provided for problem behavior
  3. Selection criteria for alternative behaviors
    • Must serve the same function as the problem behavior
    • Should be easier to perform than the problem behavior
    • Must be socially acceptable
    • Should be communicatively equivalent if replacing communication-based problems
  4. Practical examples
    • For a child who hits to gain attention: Reinforce raising hand or saying “excuse me”
    • For a client who throws materials to escape demands: Reinforce using a break card or verbally requesting a break
    • For a student who grabs toys from peers: Reinforce asking “May I have a turn?”
  5. Advantages and limitations
    • Advantages: Teaches functional communication, addresses the underlying function, socially valid
    • Limitations: Requires functional assessment, may initially increase behavior (extinction burst)

Differential Reinforcement of Incompatible Behavior (DRI)

DRI involves reinforcing a behavior that is physically incompatible with the problem behavior, making it impossible to engage in both simultaneously.

  1. Definition and purpose
    • Reinforcing behaviors that cannot physically occur at the same time as the problem behavior
    • Creates a direct competition between desired and undesired behaviors
    • Automatically decreases problem behavior through physical impossibility
  2. Implementation steps
    • Identify behaviors that are physically incompatible with the problem behavior
    • Select an incompatible behavior that is functional and socially appropriate
    • Teach the incompatible behavior if necessary
    • Reinforce the incompatible behavior consistently
    • Withhold reinforcement for the problem behavior
  3. Selection criteria for incompatible behaviors
    • Must be physically impossible to perform simultaneously with the problem behavior
    • Should be socially appropriate and practical in relevant contexts
    • Ideally serves the same function as the problem behavior
  4. Practical examples
    • For hand-biting: Reinforce keeping hands clasped or occupied with objects
    • For out-of-seat behavior: Reinforce sitting with feet on floor
    • For vocal stereotypy: Reinforce humming a tune or engaged conversation
    • For aggression: Reinforce keeping hands in pockets or folded
  5. Advantages and limitations
    • Advantages: Direct competition with problem behavior, clear incompatibility
    • Limitations: May be difficult to identify practical incompatible behaviors for some problems

Differential Reinforcement of Lower Rates of Behavior (DRL)

DRL involves reinforcing the target behavior when it occurs less frequently than a specified criterion.

  1. Definition and purpose
    • Reinforcement delivered when behavior occurs below a specified frequency
    • Used for behaviors that should be reduced but not eliminated
    • Gradually shapes behavior toward an acceptable rate
  2. Types of DRL
    • Full-session DRL: Reinforcement delivered at the end of a session if the total count is below criterion
    • Interval DRL: Reinforcement delivered at the end of intervals if the behavior occurred below criterion during that interval
    • Spaced-responding DRL: Reinforcement delivered when the behavior occurs after a minimum time has elapsed since the previous occurrence
  3. Implementation steps
    • Establish baseline rate of the target behavior
    • Set initial criterion slightly below baseline rate
    • Deliver reinforcement when behavior occurs less than the criterion
    • Gradually decrease the criterion as behavior improves
  4. Practical examples
    • For a student who raises hand excessively (20 times per hour): Set criterion at 15 times per hour, reinforcing if frequency stays below this level
    • For a client who requests breaks frequently: Reinforce if requests occur at least 10 minutes apart
    • For a child who interrupts conversations: Provide a token each hour the number of interruptions is below the established criterion
  5. Advantages and limitations
    • Advantages: Appropriate for behaviors that should be reduced but not eliminated
    • Limitations: Complex to implement, requires accurate counting, potential for end-of-interval problem behavior

Functional Communication Training (FCT)

FCT is a specific form of DRA that focuses on teaching an appropriate communicative response to replace problem behavior.

  1. Definition and purpose
    • Teaching a specific communication response that serves the same function as problem behavior
    • Provides the individual with a more effective and appropriate way to access reinforcement
    • Particularly effective for behaviors maintained by social consequences (attention, tangibles, escape)
  2. Implementation steps
    • Conduct a functional assessment to identify the function of problem behavior
    • Select an appropriate communication response based on the individual’s abilities
    • Explicitly teach the communication response
    • Provide immediate reinforcement when the communication response occurs
    • Place the problem behavior on extinction
    • Gradually shape the communication response toward more appropriate forms
  3. Selection criteria for communication responses
    • Match the individual’s communication abilities (vocal, sign, picture exchange, AAC device)
    • Start with the simplest effective form and shape toward more complex forms
    • Consider efficiency, recognizability, and social acceptability
    • Ensure the response is easy for the individual to perform
  4. Practical examples
    • For attention-maintained tantrums: Teach “Excuse me” or picture point for attention
    • For tangible-maintained aggression: Teach “My turn” or card exchange for item
    • For escape-maintained self-injury: Teach “Break please” or break card use
    • For sensory-maintained behavior: Teach request for sensory alternatives
  5. Schedule thinning in FCT
    • Initial stage: Reinforce every communication response immediately
    • Intermediate stage: Introduce delay cues (“wait” signals) with brief delays to reinforcement
    • Advanced stage: Introduce more naturalistic reinforcement schedules (e.g., “not right now,” waiting turns)
    • Use visual supports to increase tolerance for delayed reinforcement
  6. Advantages and limitations
    • Advantages: Directly addresses function, teaches valuable communication skills, high social validity
    • Limitations: May require significant teaching time, needs consistent implementation across settings

When implementing differential reinforcement procedures, it’s crucial to match the specific procedure to both the function of the behavior and the individual’s capabilities. These procedures are most effective when combined with extinction of the problem behavior and consistent implementation across environments.

D.4. Implement Extinction Procedures

Extinction involves discontinuing the reinforcement that has been maintaining a problem behavior, resulting in a decrease and eventual elimination of the behavior. This is based on the principle that behaviors that no longer produce reinforcement will eventually cease.

Understanding Extinction

  1. Definition and basic principles
    • Extinction is the discontinuation of reinforcement for a previously reinforced behavior
    • Operates on the premise that behaviors maintained by their consequences will decrease when those consequences are removed
    • Always based on the function of the behavior—must identify what is reinforcing the behavior to implement extinction effectively
  2. Function-based extinction approaches
    • Attention extinction: Withholding attention following attention-maintained behaviors
      • Example: Not providing eye contact, verbal responses, or physical intervention when a child screams for attention
    • Tangible extinction: Withholding access to items/activities following tangible-maintained behaviors
      • Example: Not providing the iPad when a client engages in aggression to access it
    • Escape extinction: Preventing escape from demands following escape-maintained behaviors
      • Example: Continuing to present demands using least-to-most prompting despite protest behaviors
    • Automatic extinction: Blocking or preventing sensory consequences for automatically reinforced behaviors
      • Example: Using protective equipment to block sensory feedback from self-injury

Implementation Steps for Extinction

  1. Preparation phase
    • Confirm the function of the behavior through assessment
    • Prepare team members and caregivers for potential extinction effects (burst, aggression)
    • Ensure consistent implementation across people and settings
    • Consider safety measures for potential escalation
  2. Implementation phase
    • Identify all sources of reinforcement and eliminate them completely
    • For attention extinction: Avoid all forms of attention (eye contact, verbal, physical)
    • For tangible extinction: Prevent access to preferred items/activities
    • For escape extinction: Continue presenting demands despite protest
    • For automatic extinction: Block sensory feedback when possible
  3. Maintenance phase
    • Continue extinction procedures consistently until behavior reduces to acceptable levels
    • Gradually fade in natural contingencies as behavior improves
    • Teach and reinforce alternative behaviors concurrently
  4. Practical implementation considerations
    • Social validity concerns: Consider how extinction appears to others in the environment
    • Consistency requirements: Must be implemented with 100% consistency across all settings
    • Safety concerns: Some behaviors cannot be safely placed on extinction (severe self-injury, aggression)
    • Combination with other procedures: Most effective when combined with differential reinforcement

Common Extinction Procedures

  1. Planned ignoring
    • Systematically withholding attention from attention-maintained behaviors
    • Includes avoiding eye contact, verbal responses, and physical contact
    • Most appropriate for minor attention-seeking behaviors
    • Example: Ignoring a child’s whining while reinforcing appropriate requests
  2. Escape extinction
    • Preventing escape from demands despite protest behaviors
    • Often involves “following through” with demands using prompting hierarchies
    • May include physical guidance as a last resort (with appropriate training and permission)
    • Example: Using three-step prompting to continue a demand despite tantrums
  3. Response blocking
    • Physically preventing the completion of a behavior or its sensory consequences
    • Used primarily for automatically reinforced behaviors
    • Example: Gentle interruption of hand-flapping, protective equipment for self-injury
    • Requires careful consideration of ethics and least restrictive alternatives
  4. Access prevention
    • Preventing access to tangible reinforcers following problem behavior
    • May involve securing items or environments to prevent unauthorized access
    • Example: Keeping preferred items out of reach until appropriate requests are made

Extinction in Context

  1. Combined with other procedures
    • Extinction is rarely used in isolation
    • Most commonly combined with:
      • Differential reinforcement (to teach alternative behaviors)
      • Antecedent strategies (to reduce the motivation for problem behavior)
      • Skill teaching (to build capacity for appropriate behaviors)
  2. Contraindications for extinction
    • Behaviors that are dangerous if they intensify during extinction burst
    • Situations where consistent implementation isn’t possible
    • Settings where extinction effects would be disruptive or unsafe
    • Cases where the function cannot be clearly identified or isolated
  3. Ethical considerations
    • Least restrictive intervention principles must be considered
    • Client dignity must be maintained throughout implementation
    • Safety concerns must be addressed prior to implementation
    • Informed consent from caregivers/guardians is essential

Implementing extinction effectively requires thorough planning, consistent application, and careful monitoring of effects. It’s essential to anticipate and prepare for extinction-related phenomena, which will be discussed in section D.6.

D.5. Implement Positive and Negative Punishment Procedures

Punishment procedures decrease the future probability of a behavior by either adding an aversive consequence (positive punishment) or removing a desirable stimulus (negative punishment). While these procedures can be effective, they should be implemented only when less intrusive methods have proven ineffective and with careful ethical consideration.

Understanding Punishment Procedures

  1. Definitions and distinctions
    • Positive punishment: Adding an aversive stimulus contingent on behavior to decrease future occurrences
    • Negative punishment: Removing a desirable stimulus contingent on behavior to decrease future occurrences
    • Both types decrease behavior but through different mechanisms
  2. Ethical and professional considerations
    • Punishment should be used only when:
      • Less restrictive alternatives have been tried and proven ineffective
      • The behavior poses significant risk to the client or others
      • Benefits outweigh potential side effects
      • Informed consent has been obtained
      • The procedure is part of a comprehensive behavior intervention plan
    • Punishment should never be used:
      • For staff convenience
      • As a substitute for teaching appropriate behaviors
      • Without approval from the supervising behavior analyst
      • Without informed consent from guardians/stakeholders

Negative Punishment Procedures

  1. Time-out from positive reinforcement
    • Definition: Temporary removal of access to reinforcement contingent upon problem behavior
    • Types of time-out:
      • Non-exclusion time-out: Remaining in the environment but without access to reinforcement
      • Exclusion time-out: Removal from the reinforcing environment but still able to observe
      • Seclusion time-out: Complete removal from the reinforcing environment (most restrictive)
  2. Implementation guidelines for time-out
    • Identify reinforcers in the environment that will be restricted
    • Determine appropriate duration (typically 1-5 minutes or until calm)
    • Select a time-out location that is safe but not reinforcing
    • Establish a release contingency (e.g., calm for 30 seconds)
    • Provide clear, brief explanation when implementing
    • Avoid attention or interaction during time-out
    • Return to activity without discussion after time-out
    • Document each implementation and outcome
  3. Response cost
    • Definition: Removal of a specific amount of reinforcement contingent on problem behavior
    • Common forms:
      • Token removal from token economy
      • Loss of privileges or preferred activities
      • Loss of points in level systems
    • Implementation guidelines:
      • Clearly define behaviors that result in response cost
      • Establish fixed “costs” for each behavior
      • Ensure sufficient reinforcement remains available
      • Apply consistently and immediately after behavior
      • Avoid emotional responses when implementing
      • Provide opportunities to earn back losses through appropriate behavior
  4. Practical examples of negative punishment
    • Removing one minute of tablet time contingent on inappropriate language
    • Taking away a token when a student calls out without raising hand
    • Brief, planned removal from group activity following aggressive behavior
    • Loss of a privilege (special outing) following property destruction

Positive Punishment Procedures

Positive punishment is rarely implemented by RBTs without specific training and close supervision. However, understanding these procedures is important for the RBT exam.

  1. Reprimands/corrective feedback
    • Brief, firm verbal correction contingent on problem behavior
    • Implementation guidelines:
      • Keep reprimands brief and direct
      • Deliver in neutral, firm tone
      • Focus on the behavior, not the person
      • Pair with instruction for appropriate alternative
    • Example: “Stop. We don’t hit. Use your words.”
  2. Overcorrection
    • Requiring the individual to restore the environment to better than original condition
    • Types:
      • Restitutional overcorrection: Fixing damage and improving beyond original state
      • Positive practice: Repeatedly practicing correct behavior
    • Implementation guidelines:
      • Ensure physical capacity to complete the overcorrection
      • Supervise throughout implementation
      • Use neutral prompting as needed
      • Complete the entire procedure regardless of protests
    • Example: A client who throws materials must pick up those materials plus straighten the entire work area
  3. Other positive punishment procedures
    • These procedures are rarely implemented by RBTs and require specialized training:
      • Contingent exercise (e.g., brief exercise contingent on behavior)
      • Environmental overcorrection (e.g., tidying beyond the immediate area affected)
      • Stimulus presentation (e.g., presentation of aversive stimuli)

Clinical Considerations for Punishment Procedures

  1. Prior requirements
    • Functional assessment must be completed
    • Less restrictive procedures must be attempted
    • Written behavior intervention plan must be in place
    • Informed consent must be obtained
    • Data collection system must be established
  2. Implementation requirements
    • Applied consistently across settings and staff
    • Implemented immediately following target behavior
    • Paired with reinforcement of alternative behaviors
    • Monitored closely for effectiveness and side effects
    • Faded as soon as clinically appropriate
  3. Contraindications
    • History of abuse or trauma
    • Risk of escalation or emotional reactivity
    • Settings where consistent implementation isn’t possible
    • When reinforcement-based alternatives have not been fully explored
  4. Documentation requirements
    • Each instance of punishment procedure must be documented
    • Documentation should include:
      • Date, time, duration
      • Antecedents and specific behavior
      • Staff implementing the procedure
      • Client response
      • Any collateral effects

When implementing punishment procedures, always remember that these strategies are part of a comprehensive plan focused on teaching skills and increasing appropriate behaviors. Punishment alone rarely leads to lasting behavior change without concurrent teaching of alternative behaviors.

D.6. Describe Secondary Effects of Extinction and Punishment

Both extinction and punishment procedures can produce secondary effects beyond the intended decrease in target behaviors. Understanding these effects is crucial for preparing clients, caregivers, and staff for implementation and ensuring proper management of these procedures.

Secondary Effects of Extinction

  1. Extinction burst
    • Definition: Temporary increase in frequency, intensity, or duration of the target behavior when extinction is first implemented
    • Characteristics:
      • Typically occurs immediately after implementation
      • May include novel topographies of the same function
      • Usually peaks within the first 1-3 days of implementation
      • Eventually decreases if extinction is implemented consistently
    • Management strategies:
      • Prepare stakeholders for likelihood of burst
      • Ensure safety measures during potential escalation
      • Maintain consistent implementation despite increased behavior
      • Collect data to document the pattern of burst and decline
    • Example: A child whose tantrums have been ignored may initially tantrum longer, louder, and more intensely before the behavior begins to decrease
  2. Response variation
    • Definition: Changes in the topography (form) of behavior while maintaining the same function
    • Characteristics:
      • New forms of behavior emerge attempting to access the same reinforcer
      • May include behaviors never previously observed
      • Can occur throughout the extinction process
    • Management strategies:
      • Identify potential variations before implementation
      • Extend extinction to all variations of the behavior
      • Maintain consistent implementation across topographies
      • Document new topographies as they emerge
    • Example: A child who initially screams for attention may switch to property destruction when screaming is placed on extinction
  3. Resurgence
    • Definition: Re-emergence of previously extinguished behaviors when current behaviors are placed on extinction
    • Characteristics:
      • Previously successful behaviors return when new behaviors are ineffective
      • Often behaviors from earlier in developmental history
      • Typically temporary if extinction remains consistent
    • Management strategies:
      • Review behavioral history to anticipate potential resurgence
      • Apply extinction procedures to resurging behaviors
      • Maintain reinforcement for appropriate alternative behaviors
      • Continue data collection on all topographies of behavior
    • Example: A client who previously hit to escape demands and was taught to request breaks may return to hitting when break requests are placed on an interval schedule
  4. Emotional responding
    • Definition: Emotional reactions that occur when expected reinforcement is withheld
    • Characteristics:
      • May include crying, agitation, frustration, aggression
      • Often most intense at beginning of extinction
      • May include collateral behaviors not directly targeted
    • Management strategies:
      • Prepare for emotional responses before implementation
      • Distinguish between target behaviors and emotional reactions
      • Monitor intensity and duration of emotional responses
      • Consider pairing extinction with relaxation or coping skills training
    • Example: A child may become tearful or verbally protest when attention is withheld for attention-seeking behavior
  5. Spontaneous recovery
    • Definition: Temporary re-emergence of extinguished behavior after a period of non-occurrence
    • Characteristics:
      • Often occurs after periods of no exposure to extinction contingencies
      • Typically at lower intensity than original behavior
      • Usually brief if extinction continues to be implemented
    • Management strategies:
      • Prepare stakeholders for possibility of re-emergence
      • Continue extinction procedures consistently
      • Maintain reinforcement of alternative behaviors
      • Document patterns of recovery to identify triggers
    • Example: A behavior that appeared extinguished may reappear after a vacation, illness, or change in routine

Secondary Effects of Punishment

  1. Emotional responses
    • Definition: Emotional reactions to the aversive nature of punishment
    • Common responses:
      • Fear or anxiety in situations where punishment occurred
      • Anger or aggression toward those implementing punishment
      • Avoidance of settings associated with punishment
      • Crying, withdrawal, or emotional distress
    • Management considerations:
      • Monitor emotional state during and after punishment
      • Balance punishment with positive reinforcement
      • Teach coping strategies for managing emotional responses
      • Consider fading punishment if severe emotional reactions occur
    • Example: A child may become anxious when entering a classroom where time-out has been frequently implemented
  2. Escape and avoidance
    • Definition: Behaviors that develop to escape or avoid punishment contingencies
    • Characteristics:
      • Development of new behaviors to avoid punishment situations
      • Refusal to enter environments where punishment occurs
      • Eloping from situations associated with punishment
    • Management considerations:
      • Monitor for emerging escape/avoidance patterns
      • Pair punishment environments with positive reinforcement
      • Teach appropriate ways to request breaks or assistance
      • Balance demand environments with reinforcement opportunities
    • Examples: A student may claim illness to avoid school where response cost is used; a client may elope when seeing the timer used for time-out
  3. Negative reinforcement of punisher’s behavior
    • Definition: The implementer’s behavior of punishing is reinforced by the temporary suppression of problem behavior
    • Characteristics:
      • Increased frequency of punishment implementation
      • Reliance on punishment rather than teaching strategies
      • Escalation in punishment intensity over time
    • Management considerations:
      • Strict adherence to behavior intervention plan guidelines
      • Regular supervision and feedback on implementation
      • Data-based decision making for procedure modifications
      • Training in reinforcement-based alternatives
    • Example: Staff may increase use of time-out procedures due to the immediate (but temporary) suppression of problem behavior
  4. Punishment-induced aggression
    • Definition: Aggressive behaviors that emerge as a direct response to punishment
    • Characteristics:
      • May be directed at the punisher or displaced to others
      • Often occurs immediately following punishment
      • May become part of an escalation cycle
    • Management considerations:
      • Assess risk factors for aggressive responses before implementation
      • Monitor for early signs of agitation or aggression
      • Have de-escalation procedures in place
      • Consider less aversive alternatives if aggression emerges
    • Example: A client who receives response cost may engage in aggression toward the staff implementing the procedure
  5. Habituation and adaptation
    • Definition: Decreased effectiveness of punishment over time as the individual adapts to the punisher
    • Characteristics:
      • Gradually diminishing effect of the same level of punishment
      • Need for increased intensity to maintain effectiveness
      • Eventually complete ineffectiveness of the procedure
    • Management considerations:
      • Monitor effectiveness data consistently
      • Avoid escalating punishment intensity
      • Shift to alternative strategies when effectiveness decreases
      • Focus on teaching replacement behaviors
    • Example: A client may initially respond to brief time-outs but gradually show less behavior change from the same procedure

Mitigating Secondary Effects

  1. Comprehensive intervention approach
    • Always pair extinction/punishment with:
      • Teaching functional replacement behaviors
      • Differential reinforcement procedures
      • Antecedent interventions to prevent behavior
    • Focus on skill development rather than behavior suppression
  2. Consistency in implementation
    • Train all implementers to respond consistently
    • Develop clear protocols for managing secondary effects
    • Maintain consistent implementation despite initial worsening
    • Regular team meetings to address challenges
  3. Environmental considerations
    • Enrich the overall environment with reinforcement opportunities
    • Create supportive settings that minimize the need for punishment
    • Make punishment contingencies clear and predictable
    • Provide abundant positive interactions outside of punishment contexts
  4. Ethical decision-making
    • Continually evaluate whether benefits outweigh side effects
    • Consider least-restrictive alternatives as behavior improves
    • Fade punishment components as soon as clinically appropriate
    • Prioritize dignity and respect throughout implementation

Understanding and preparing for these secondary effects is essential for ethical and effective implementation of behavior reduction procedures. Stakeholders should be fully informed about potential effects before implementation, and comprehensive data collection should monitor both target behaviors and secondary effects throughout intervention.

D.7. Implement Crisis/Emergency Procedures

Crisis and emergency procedures are essential components of behavior intervention that focus on maintaining safety when behaviors escalate beyond typical intervention procedures. As an RBT, you must be prepared to implement these procedures correctly and efficiently when challenging behaviors pose immediate risks.

Understanding Behavioral Crises

  1. Definition and identification
    • A behavioral crisis involves behaviors that:
      • Present immediate danger to the individual or others
      • Cannot be safely managed through typical intervention procedures
      • Require immediate intervention to prevent harm
      • Exceed the parameters of the regular behavior plan
    • Examples include:
      • Severe self-injury that could cause tissue damage
      • Aggression that could injure others
      • Elopement into dangerous situations
      • Property destruction that creates safety hazards
  2. The crisis cycle
    • Calm phase: Typical functioning and responsive to normal interventions
    • Trigger phase: Events that initiate escalation (demands, transitions, etc.)
    • Agitation phase: Increased anxiety, minor problem behaviors, decreased rationality
    • Acceleration phase: Problem behaviors increase in intensity and frequency
    • Peak/crisis phase: Maximum intensity of behavior, safety concerns predominate
    • De-escalation phase: Gradual decrease in intensity, increased receptiveness
    • Recovery phase: Return to baseline, often with fatigue or embarrassment
  3. Prevention-focused approach
    • Primary prevention: Environmental arrangements and teaching that prevent crises
    • Secondary prevention: Early intervention when precursor behaviors appear
    • Tertiary prevention: Crisis management procedures when prevention fails

Crisis Prevention and De-escalation

  1. Recognizing precursor behaviors
    • Early warning signs that may precede crisis:
      • Changes in body language (muscle tension, pacing, breathing)
      • Verbal indicators (tone changes, volume increases, threats)
      • Behavioral indicators (fidgeting, property misuse, non-compliance)
      • Physiological signs (flushed face, sweating, pupil dilation)
    • Response strategies for precursors:
      • Environmental modifications (reduce demands, stimulation, audience)
      • Prompting coping/calming strategies
      • Redirection to preferred activities
      • Offering choices to increase sense of control
  2. De-escalation techniques
    • Verbal de-escalation:
      • Use calm, neutral tone of voice
      • Simplify language and instructions
      • Avoid threats, challenges, or power struggles
      • Validate feelings without condoning behavior
      • Offer clear, simple choices when appropriate
    • Environmental de-escalation:
      • Remove triggers or sources of stimulation
      • Create space and distance
      • Clear the area of dangerous items
      • Reduce audience effect by removing peers/onlookers
      • Provide access to calming areas or activities
    • Sensory de-escalation:
      • Reduce sensory input (dimming lights, reducing noise)
      • Offer proprioceptive activities if appropriate
      • Provide access to calming sensory tools
      • Create physical and emotional space
  3. Staff approaches during escalation
    • Maintain personal control:
      • Manage your own emotional responses
      • Use calm body language and neutral facial expressions
      • Maintain safe positioning and awareness of exits
      • Follow breathing and self-calming techniques
    • Team coordination:
      • Use predetermined signals for assistance
      • Assign clear roles during crisis situations
      • Maintain communication with minimal verbal exchange
      • Follow established protocols without deviation

Crisis Management Procedures

  1. Physical safety measures
    • Environmental safety:
      • Clearing the area of dangerous objects
      • Moving others to safety
      • Creating adequate space for safe management
      • Securing doors/exits if elopement risk exists
    • Personal safety positioning:
      • Maintaining safe distance (typically arm’s length plus)
      • Avoiding cornering the individual
      • Positioning near exits
      • Avoiding turning your back or vulnerable positions
  2. Emergency behavioral interventions
    • Redirection:
      • Physical guidance to alternative activities
      • Verbal prompts to engage in incompatible behaviors
      • Visual cues for appropriate behaviors
      • Environmental redirection (changing settings)
    • Proximity control:
      • Strategic use of physical proximity
      • Moving closer or farther based on the individual’s response
      • Using your presence as a calming influence
    • Removal of others:
      • Moving peers/others away from crisis situation
      • Ensuring supervision of all clients during emergency
      • Designating staff for managing non-crisis clients
  3. Physical management and restraint considerations
    • Note: RBTs should only implement physical interventions with:
      • Specific crisis management certification
      • Training in the specific procedures used
      • Direct supervision and authorization
      • Clear protocols in the behavior intervention plan
    • Physical restraint hierarchy:
      • Physical restraint as absolute last resort when imminent danger exists
      • Use least restrictive form necessary to ensure safety
      • Implement only for the minimum time necessary
      • Release at earliest safe opportunity
    • Monitoring during restraint:
      • Continuous assessment of breathing and circulation
      • Monitoring for signs of distress
      • Communication with the individual throughout
      • Regular checks for ability to release safely
  4. Post-crisis procedures
    • Immediate aftermath:
      • Ensure physical safety of all involved
      • Provide space and time for recovery
      • Return to structure and routine when appropriate
      • Avoid discussing the incident during emotional recovery
    • Documentation requirements:
      • Detailed incident reports according to agency policy
      • Objective description of behaviors and interventions
      • Timeline of events including duration of each phase
      • Notification to supervisor, guardian, or other parties as required
    • Debriefing process:
      • Team discussion of triggers and effectiveness of interventions
      • Review of prevention strategies that could be implemented
      • Adjustments to behavior intervention plan as needed
      • Support for staff and clients affected by the crisis

Crisis Prevention and Intervention Planning

  1. Individualized crisis plans
    • Should include:
      • Specific operational definitions of crisis behaviors
      • Known triggers and precursors
      • Preventive strategies for each phase of escalation
      • Specific de-escalation techniques that have been effective
      • Clear hierarchy of interventions from least to most restrictive
      • Staff roles and responsibilities during crisis
      • Post-crisis procedures and documentation requirements
    • Key components:
      • Proactive strategies focused on prevention
      • Clearly defined criteria for emergency procedures
      • Specific, individualized interventions based on function
      • Regular review and updates based on data
  2. Staff training requirements
    • Required knowledge:
      • Understanding of the individual’s behavior support plan
      • Recognition of escalation patterns specific to the individual
      • Knowledge of function-based intervention approaches
      • Familiarity with crisis cycle and intervention points
    • Required skills:
      • De-escalation techniques appropriate to the setting
      • Safety procedures for self and others
      • Implementation of emergency interventions
      • Documentation and reporting procedures
  3. Legal and ethical considerations
    • Informed consent:
      • Ensure guardians understand and consent to emergency procedures
      • Document all discussions regarding crisis procedures
      • Review and renew consent regularly
    • Regulatory requirements:
      • Follow agency and state policies regarding emergency interventions
      • Adhere to required reporting and documentation standards
      • Maintain certification in approved crisis management systems
      • Report serious incidents to appropriate authorities
    • Ethical practice:
      • Use least restrictive interventions necessary
      • Implement procedures only for safety, never convenience
      • Focus on prevention and skill building
      • Regularly evaluate necessity of crisis procedures

Practice Examples: Crisis Scenarios

  1. Scenario: Self-injurious behavior escalation
    • Client begins hitting head against wall with increasing force
    • Appropriate RBT response sequence:
      • Clear area of other clients
      • Implement verbal de-escalation with simple, calm directives
      • Introduce crisis prevention techniques (e.g., redirection)
      • If trained and authorized, introduce protective equipment or blocking
      • Follow crisis plan for self-injury specific to this client
      • Document incident thoroughly following agency procedures
  2. Scenario: Aggression toward peers
    • Client becomes agitated and begins threatening peers
    • Appropriate RBT response sequence:
      • Position yourself between client and potential targets
      • Direct other staff to remove peers from the area
      • Use calm, simple language to direct client
      • Offer acceptable alternatives for expressing frustration
      • Create sufficient space to minimize risk
      • Implement specific crisis protocols for aggression
      • Document incident and notify supervisor immediately
  3. Scenario: Elopement attempt
    • Client attempts to flee from instructional setting toward parking lot
    • Appropriate RBT response sequence:
      • Alert other staff using predetermined signal
      • Maintain visual contact with client
      • Use clear, simple directives to stop
      • Implement approved elopement prevention strategies
      • If trained and authorized, use approved containment procedures
      • After situation is controlled, notify supervisor and document

When implementing crisis procedures, always remember that the primary goal is safety—not behavior change. Crisis intervention is a temporary measure to maintain safety until the individual can return to typical intervention approaches. Long-term behavior change comes through consistent implementation of the comprehensive behavior plan, not through crisis management.

Final Thoughts on Behavior Reduction

Understanding and effectively implementing behavior reduction strategies is a critical skill set for any RBT. While these procedures are designed to decrease problematic behaviors, it’s essential to remember that behavior reduction is just one component of a comprehensive behavioral approach. True success comes when behavior reduction is paired with teaching alternative, appropriate behaviors that enable the individual to meet their needs in socially acceptable ways.

Key Principles to Remember

  1. Function-based intervention
    • All behavior reduction procedures should be based on the identified function of the behavior
    • The most effective interventions address the underlying motivation rather than just the topography
    • Function identification should be an ongoing process as behaviors and motivations can change
  2. Least restrictive approach
    • Always begin with the least restrictive procedures that could be effective
    • Use a hierarchy approach, progressing to more restrictive procedures only when necessary
    • Return to less restrictive procedures as soon as behavior improvement allows
  3. Positive emphasis
    • Even when implementing behavior reduction, maintain a focus on teaching and reinforcing positive behaviors
    • Create opportunities for success rather than simply eliminating unwanted behaviors
    • Remember that the goal is skill development, not just behavior suppression
  4. Consistency and coordination
    • Behavior reduction procedures are most effective when implemented consistently across settings
    • Communication among all stakeholders is essential for consistent implementation
    • Regular team meetings and training enhance procedural integrity
  5. Data-based decision making
    • Collect and analyze data on both target behaviors and replacement behaviors
    • Use objective data rather than subjective impressions to evaluate effectiveness
    • Be willing to adjust procedures based on data showing insufficient progress
  6. Ethical implementation
    • Always consider dignity, respect, and quality of life in behavior reduction
    • Regularly evaluate whether procedures remain necessary and appropriate
    • Ensure informed consent is maintained throughout implementation
    • Consider social validity of procedures and outcomes

Integrating Behavior Reduction with Skill Development

The most effective approach to behavior reduction incorporates these elements:

  1. Teaching functional equivalents
    • Identify behaviors that serve the same function but are more appropriate
    • Explicitly teach these replacement behaviors with sufficient practice
    • Ensure replacement behaviors are as efficient and effective as problem behaviors
  2. Building skill deficits
    • Identify skill deficits that contribute to problem behavior
    • Develop systematic instruction to address these deficits
    • Prioritize skills that prevent the need for problem behavior
  3. Environmental engineering
    • Arrange environments to minimize triggers for problem behavior
    • Create supportive settings that prompt appropriate behaviors
    • Modify tasks and expectations to match current skill levels
  4. Building self-management
    • Teach awareness of emotional and behavioral states
    • Develop self-monitoring skills appropriate to developmental level
    • Gradually transfer control from external supports to internal regulation

Continuous Professional Development

As an RBT implementing behavior reduction procedures, commit to:

  1. Ongoing learning
    • Stay current with best practices in behavior reduction
    • Seek additional training in specialized techniques
    • Participate in supervision that enhances your skills
  2. Self-evaluation
    • Regularly assess your implementation of procedures
    • Seek feedback on your technique and approach
    • Be receptive to coaching and guidance
  3. Ethical vigilance
    • Continuously evaluate whether procedures remain in the client’s best interest
    • Advocate for modifications when circumstances change
    • Maintain focus on dignity and respect throughout implementation
  4. Collaborative practice
    • Work closely with the supervising behavior analyst
    • Communicate effectively with all team members
    • Value input from caregivers and other stakeholders

Remember that as an RBT, your role in behavior reduction is both technical and human. While you must implement procedures with precision and consistency, you are also a crucial support for individuals working to develop more effective behavioral repertoires. Your compassionate and skilled implementation of behavior reduction procedures can make a profound difference in helping clients achieve greater independence and quality of life.

By thoroughly understanding the principles and procedures covered in this guide—from identifying behavioral functions to implementing crisis procedures—you will be well-prepared to address challenging behaviors effectively and ethically in your practice as an RBT and to successfully complete the behavior reduction section of the RBT examination.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *